SPORTS HISTORY BLOG
Over 250 articles on all aspects of Scottish sport
- Published on
James Weir (1851-1889), Scotland internationalist and hero
A tale of heroism by one of Scottish football’s pioneers, James Weir, has come to light thanks to an anecdote by one of his contemporaries.
Archie Hunter, a star with Aston Villa in the 1880s, wrote a series of reminiscences in which he described a drunken episode which ended with Weir being hailed as the hero of a major fire in Glasgow’s south side.
Weir was capped four times by Scotland, including the first ever international in 1872, and won the Scottish Cup three times with Queen’s Park. He was known as the ‘Prince of Dribblers’, an accolade which Hunter said was fully deserved: “I think he was the best forward in Scotland, and when he once got possession of the ball no one could take it from him. If you could have seen him play you would have remembered it. He was a merry fellow, always ready for fun and when the game was over no one liked a frolic better than he did.”
Hunter recalled a night out in Glasgow which would not be out of place among today’s footballers: “A few of us were going home together and Jimmy Weir was in a fine rollicking mood. He had been – well, celebrating a victory that day – and he was amusing us with his little pranks and his livery chatter. We were all in the best of spirits and made a merry little party.
“All at once we were startled by a loud alarm in the street and a cry of Fire! Fire! The people, excited as they always are on such occasions, began to run in the direction indicated by a red glare in the distance and we followed them. Sure enough a house was on fire and the flames were getting a firm hold on the building. Worse than that, there were people in the house and already there was such a blaze that they found it hard to make their way to the doors.
“Presently, amid all the smoke and flame we saw a face at one of the topmost windows – a face that looked ghastly in the glare and was full of horror and despair. There were no ladders at hand and the lower part of the building was ablaze. It looked as if the poor creature – whether man or woman we could not distinguish – must be burnt to death in that furnace.
“Well, Jimmy was a carpenter by trade and I suppose he knew something about climbing up and down houses. What did he do but coolly commence to climb up a high wall, from which he could throw a rope to the poor creature who was in such terrible danger. We watched him go up and before very long – though it seemed a long time then – he managed to bring the poor thing down; and how he was cheered by the people to be sure! His heroism wasn’t soon forgotten.”
It is a fascinating story, and what is more it is entirely true. I recently stumbled across a report of the incident in the Glasgow Herald of 26 February 1877.
Shortly after 12 on Saturday night, a serious fire occurred at No Man’s Land, whereby a fine tenement of shops and dwelling houses was burned, the furniture and fittings destroyed, and the lives of the occupants placed in imminent danger. The tenement was situated at the corner of Winton Terrace (Victoria Road) and Allison Street, with a frontage to each thoroughfare of about 90 feet, and was four storeys in height. The ground flat was occupied as shops – a general store, conducted on the American principle and carried on by Mr James Graham, and a fruiterer’s and two drapers’ premises. The flats above, which were divided into dwellings of four rooms and kitchen, and five rooms and kitchen, were fully occupied by five families. The fire originated in Mr Graham’s store, whence it spread with great rapidity.
The report explained how residents were alerted by the local police sergeant, Mr Taylor, who climbed the tenement stairs to the top level, shouting ‘Fire’ as he went. But he was not alone:
Mr Weir, well known in football circles, also lent admirable assistance in making the inmates aware of the alarming position in which they were placed – a task which was not accomplished without considerable difficulty. When there were still a number of persons within the building, the flames had burst into the lobby, but Taylor and Mr Weir succeeded in penetrating through them and a second time reaching the upper flats, where were found a number of people in a terror-stricken state. It was impossible to reach the street through the lobby.
Fortunately, a balcony ran along the front of the second storey, and the sergeant at once stepped on to the balcony, and passing along to the south end he saw that if the parties could be landed on the window sill of a house in the adjoining tenement they would be safe. By a loud knocking on the window he attracted the attention of a young man who was within, and by his aid got the window opened.
Nobody was killed but the tenement was destroyed which is why the building now on that site in Victoria Road is a different style to the rest of the street. The paper praised the efforts of the rescuers: “There seemed throughout a generous resignation of self”.
On the day of the rescue, Weir and Hunter had both played for the ‘Improbables’ in the Scotland international trial, which their team won 3-0; the match report in the Herald was on the opposite page to the story of the fire.
Weir’s life was certainly not lacking in drama. In 1881 he emigrated to Australia, a course that would eventually lead to his death in the outback eight years later, a story I outlined in my book First Elevens. The death notice was in the Adelaide Advertiser:
WEIR.—On the 23rd April, at Warrina Hospital, Great Northern Extension Railway, after an illness of 3 weeks and 3 days, James Biger Weir, of typhoid fever and congestion of the lungs. Deeply regretted by his wife.
When the book came out, I did not know the identity of his wife but have since discovered her name - and that leads to another tale. They married in Adelaide on 3 November 1886, and the reason I know is that they celebrated rather too much:
Archie Hunter, a star with Aston Villa in the 1880s, wrote a series of reminiscences in which he described a drunken episode which ended with Weir being hailed as the hero of a major fire in Glasgow’s south side.
Weir was capped four times by Scotland, including the first ever international in 1872, and won the Scottish Cup three times with Queen’s Park. He was known as the ‘Prince of Dribblers’, an accolade which Hunter said was fully deserved: “I think he was the best forward in Scotland, and when he once got possession of the ball no one could take it from him. If you could have seen him play you would have remembered it. He was a merry fellow, always ready for fun and when the game was over no one liked a frolic better than he did.”
Hunter recalled a night out in Glasgow which would not be out of place among today’s footballers: “A few of us were going home together and Jimmy Weir was in a fine rollicking mood. He had been – well, celebrating a victory that day – and he was amusing us with his little pranks and his livery chatter. We were all in the best of spirits and made a merry little party.
“All at once we were startled by a loud alarm in the street and a cry of Fire! Fire! The people, excited as they always are on such occasions, began to run in the direction indicated by a red glare in the distance and we followed them. Sure enough a house was on fire and the flames were getting a firm hold on the building. Worse than that, there were people in the house and already there was such a blaze that they found it hard to make their way to the doors.
“Presently, amid all the smoke and flame we saw a face at one of the topmost windows – a face that looked ghastly in the glare and was full of horror and despair. There were no ladders at hand and the lower part of the building was ablaze. It looked as if the poor creature – whether man or woman we could not distinguish – must be burnt to death in that furnace.
“Well, Jimmy was a carpenter by trade and I suppose he knew something about climbing up and down houses. What did he do but coolly commence to climb up a high wall, from which he could throw a rope to the poor creature who was in such terrible danger. We watched him go up and before very long – though it seemed a long time then – he managed to bring the poor thing down; and how he was cheered by the people to be sure! His heroism wasn’t soon forgotten.”
It is a fascinating story, and what is more it is entirely true. I recently stumbled across a report of the incident in the Glasgow Herald of 26 February 1877.
Shortly after 12 on Saturday night, a serious fire occurred at No Man’s Land, whereby a fine tenement of shops and dwelling houses was burned, the furniture and fittings destroyed, and the lives of the occupants placed in imminent danger. The tenement was situated at the corner of Winton Terrace (Victoria Road) and Allison Street, with a frontage to each thoroughfare of about 90 feet, and was four storeys in height. The ground flat was occupied as shops – a general store, conducted on the American principle and carried on by Mr James Graham, and a fruiterer’s and two drapers’ premises. The flats above, which were divided into dwellings of four rooms and kitchen, and five rooms and kitchen, were fully occupied by five families. The fire originated in Mr Graham’s store, whence it spread with great rapidity.
The report explained how residents were alerted by the local police sergeant, Mr Taylor, who climbed the tenement stairs to the top level, shouting ‘Fire’ as he went. But he was not alone:
Mr Weir, well known in football circles, also lent admirable assistance in making the inmates aware of the alarming position in which they were placed – a task which was not accomplished without considerable difficulty. When there were still a number of persons within the building, the flames had burst into the lobby, but Taylor and Mr Weir succeeded in penetrating through them and a second time reaching the upper flats, where were found a number of people in a terror-stricken state. It was impossible to reach the street through the lobby.
Fortunately, a balcony ran along the front of the second storey, and the sergeant at once stepped on to the balcony, and passing along to the south end he saw that if the parties could be landed on the window sill of a house in the adjoining tenement they would be safe. By a loud knocking on the window he attracted the attention of a young man who was within, and by his aid got the window opened.
Nobody was killed but the tenement was destroyed which is why the building now on that site in Victoria Road is a different style to the rest of the street. The paper praised the efforts of the rescuers: “There seemed throughout a generous resignation of self”.
On the day of the rescue, Weir and Hunter had both played for the ‘Improbables’ in the Scotland international trial, which their team won 3-0; the match report in the Herald was on the opposite page to the story of the fire.
Weir’s life was certainly not lacking in drama. In 1881 he emigrated to Australia, a course that would eventually lead to his death in the outback eight years later, a story I outlined in my book First Elevens. The death notice was in the Adelaide Advertiser:
WEIR.—On the 23rd April, at Warrina Hospital, Great Northern Extension Railway, after an illness of 3 weeks and 3 days, James Biger Weir, of typhoid fever and congestion of the lungs. Deeply regretted by his wife.
When the book came out, I did not know the identity of his wife but have since discovered her name - and that leads to another tale. They married in Adelaide on 3 November 1886, and the reason I know is that they celebrated rather too much:
His wife’s story is quite incredible, too. Born Emma Jane Tampion in 1858, she crops up regularly in newspaper reports. Her parents divorced in 1869, three years later she absconded from Adelaide Industrial School, and she married no less than five times.
James Weir was her third husband, and she wasted no time in finding a fourth as she married a Thomas Neylon less than two months after Weir’s death. There are reports through the 1890s of Emma Neylon being fined for drunkenness but she must have sobered up eventually as in 1907 she married her fifth husband and lived until 1937.
James Biggar Weir
Born 21 October 1851 in Gorbals, Glasgow.
Died 23 April 1889 at Warrina, South Australia.
James Weir was her third husband, and she wasted no time in finding a fourth as she married a Thomas Neylon less than two months after Weir’s death. There are reports through the 1890s of Emma Neylon being fined for drunkenness but she must have sobered up eventually as in 1907 she married her fifth husband and lived until 1937.
James Biggar Weir
Born 21 October 1851 in Gorbals, Glasgow.
Died 23 April 1889 at Warrina, South Australia.
- Published on
When I worked at the Scottish FA a few years back, there were regular rumblings from the press that they weren't allowed to attend Council meetings and report on the deliberations. I tried to assure them that they would regret ever being allowed in, such was the quality and length of the debates.
However, it wasn't always that way, and in the early days there would always be a journalist or two in attendance. For researchers, their reports give a valuable insight to football politics in the Victorian era. And sometimes a gem can be found, such as this delightful spat in November 1898 which was reported verbatim in the Dundee Courier and is given here in full. The chairman was SFA President JD McLean of Ayr Parkhouse, his opponent was Alex Kirkwood of Airdrieonians, who happened to live in Dykehead.
TREATMENT OF REFEREES
A letter was read from Mr Watson, who was referee in the Federation match, Cameronians v Dykehead at Dykehead. He had to order off the field Steven, of the home club, for rough play. He also reported McLaren, of Dykehead, for using bad language to the visiting linesman, Mr Ramsay. Mr Watson also said that at the end of the game, which was finished twenty minutes before the time owing to darkness, he was invited into the pavilion, and struck by a Dykehead committee man. He was glad to get out, so threatening was the man in question.
After a discussion, which lasted an hour, it was agreed to suspend both players for one month, and ask the Dykehead to give an explanation of the assault on the referee. This led to a 'scene' with Mr Kirkwood, of Dykehead.
The Chairman was on his feet, speaking when Mr Kirkwood (interrupting) said - I wish to say---
The Chairman - Sit down, Mr Kirkwood.
Mr Kirkwood - I defy you to keep me from speaking.
The Chairman - I shall hear you after I'm done.
Mr Kirkwood - I shall speak of what I like, and when I like. (Cries of 'Chair'). I never heard a chairman give such an extraordinary judgement. To ask a club to come and produce evidence against itself was absurd. I never heard a chairman put forward such a proposition, and I hope I never will. (Cries of 'Chair').
The Chairman - We must have no more insolence. Sit down, sir.
Mr Kirkwood - You won't put me down. ('Chair')
The Chairman - I will see you afterwards.
Mr Hood (Beith) - It is foolish for any club to be asked to incriminate itself.
Mr McLaughlin (Celtic) - It is clear as day from the evidence on hand that the referee has been assaulted, and the Dykehead is trying to shield the man who did it.
Mr McCulloch (Dundee) - It is not a hundred years since a club was ordered to produce its own books to enable others to prove their case, but then it was a northern club.
Upon a vote, the amendment received only 8 votes.
Ah, they don't behave like that any more. Or do they?
Postscript: in 1900, less than two years later, Alex Kirkwood was elected President of the Scottish Football Association.
However, it wasn't always that way, and in the early days there would always be a journalist or two in attendance. For researchers, their reports give a valuable insight to football politics in the Victorian era. And sometimes a gem can be found, such as this delightful spat in November 1898 which was reported verbatim in the Dundee Courier and is given here in full. The chairman was SFA President JD McLean of Ayr Parkhouse, his opponent was Alex Kirkwood of Airdrieonians, who happened to live in Dykehead.
TREATMENT OF REFEREES
A letter was read from Mr Watson, who was referee in the Federation match, Cameronians v Dykehead at Dykehead. He had to order off the field Steven, of the home club, for rough play. He also reported McLaren, of Dykehead, for using bad language to the visiting linesman, Mr Ramsay. Mr Watson also said that at the end of the game, which was finished twenty minutes before the time owing to darkness, he was invited into the pavilion, and struck by a Dykehead committee man. He was glad to get out, so threatening was the man in question.
After a discussion, which lasted an hour, it was agreed to suspend both players for one month, and ask the Dykehead to give an explanation of the assault on the referee. This led to a 'scene' with Mr Kirkwood, of Dykehead.
The Chairman was on his feet, speaking when Mr Kirkwood (interrupting) said - I wish to say---
The Chairman - Sit down, Mr Kirkwood.
Mr Kirkwood - I defy you to keep me from speaking.
The Chairman - I shall hear you after I'm done.
Mr Kirkwood - I shall speak of what I like, and when I like. (Cries of 'Chair'). I never heard a chairman give such an extraordinary judgement. To ask a club to come and produce evidence against itself was absurd. I never heard a chairman put forward such a proposition, and I hope I never will. (Cries of 'Chair').
The Chairman - We must have no more insolence. Sit down, sir.
Mr Kirkwood - You won't put me down. ('Chair')
The Chairman - I will see you afterwards.
Mr Hood (Beith) - It is foolish for any club to be asked to incriminate itself.
Mr McLaughlin (Celtic) - It is clear as day from the evidence on hand that the referee has been assaulted, and the Dykehead is trying to shield the man who did it.
Mr McCulloch (Dundee) - It is not a hundred years since a club was ordered to produce its own books to enable others to prove their case, but then it was a northern club.
Upon a vote, the amendment received only 8 votes.
Ah, they don't behave like that any more. Or do they?
Postscript: in 1900, less than two years later, Alex Kirkwood was elected President of the Scottish Football Association.
- Published on
One of the macabre fascinations of researching international footballers is finding out what happened to them at the end of their lives. It can make for sad reading at times. Two recent discoveries which jumped out at me were those of men who were once famous as Scottish Cup winners, yet both died in an asylum.
John Rae, known as Spriggie, won the cup with Thirds and the first of two Scotland caps in 1889, and that fame no doubt helped him the following year to earn a bit of cash by signing for Sunderland Albion. At a time when Scottish football was nominally amateur, many high profile players went south, but unfortunately Albion was a short-lived rival to Sunderland FC. When the latter won the Football League title in 1892, Albion was wound up, and Rae was left without a club. Thankfully, Third Lanark took him back, but his playing career was over by 1894 at the age of 31. He reverted to his 'day job' as a colliery engine keeper, living on the Rutherglen Road at Shawfield Bank House, just across the road from Shawfield Stadium. He was still there in the 1911 census, by then a widower, but his death was only a few years away. He died at Hartwood Asylum in Shotts on 20 November 1917, from 'general paralysis of the insane' - medical term for the final stage of syphilis. In the days before antibiotics, it was a killer disease with no effective treatment.
Another to meet a gruesome end was David Stewart, Scottish Cup winner in 1893 with Queen's Park, and selected three times for Scotland; his brother Andrew was also a Scotland international and, as it happens, a teammate of John Rae at Third Lanark. The Stewarts had a prosperous upbringing in Partick, sons of the proprietor of Western Saw Mills. David, like many QP men, was a professional man - a consulting engineer - but he fell victim to mental illness. His death notice in the Glasgow Herald simply stated that he had died in Perth after a lengthy illness, but the death certificate, dated 3 August 1933, revealed rather more. The end came in Murray's Royal Asylum (now known as the Murray Royal Hospital but still a specialist centre for mental illness). His cause of death was recorded as 'suicidal strangulation', conjuring up horrible images of a man who was so deranged that he took his own life.
John Rae, known as Spriggie, won the cup with Thirds and the first of two Scotland caps in 1889, and that fame no doubt helped him the following year to earn a bit of cash by signing for Sunderland Albion. At a time when Scottish football was nominally amateur, many high profile players went south, but unfortunately Albion was a short-lived rival to Sunderland FC. When the latter won the Football League title in 1892, Albion was wound up, and Rae was left without a club. Thankfully, Third Lanark took him back, but his playing career was over by 1894 at the age of 31. He reverted to his 'day job' as a colliery engine keeper, living on the Rutherglen Road at Shawfield Bank House, just across the road from Shawfield Stadium. He was still there in the 1911 census, by then a widower, but his death was only a few years away. He died at Hartwood Asylum in Shotts on 20 November 1917, from 'general paralysis of the insane' - medical term for the final stage of syphilis. In the days before antibiotics, it was a killer disease with no effective treatment.
Another to meet a gruesome end was David Stewart, Scottish Cup winner in 1893 with Queen's Park, and selected three times for Scotland; his brother Andrew was also a Scotland international and, as it happens, a teammate of John Rae at Third Lanark. The Stewarts had a prosperous upbringing in Partick, sons of the proprietor of Western Saw Mills. David, like many QP men, was a professional man - a consulting engineer - but he fell victim to mental illness. His death notice in the Glasgow Herald simply stated that he had died in Perth after a lengthy illness, but the death certificate, dated 3 August 1933, revealed rather more. The end came in Murray's Royal Asylum (now known as the Murray Royal Hospital but still a specialist centre for mental illness). His cause of death was recorded as 'suicidal strangulation', conjuring up horrible images of a man who was so deranged that he took his own life.
- Published on
There's often something unexpected when researching old footballers, but I had never come across the Fremantle Lumpers' Union before now. But they helped to solve a mystery that has been challenging me recently: what happened to Charles Winton Heggie?
Heggie was a Rangers forward in the 1880s, not one of the greats but he had a fine eye for goal and was duly selected to play for Scotland against Ireland in March 1886. He was the outstanding player in a 7-2 victory, scoring no less than four of Scotland's goals - yet he was never capped again. He wound down his career at St Bernard's in Edinburgh, and was also an occasional referee, but there was no indication as to what happened to him after that. With an unusual name, it was little difficulty to confirm his date of birth (26 September 1862), a marriage in 1886 to Mary McIntosh, and a son William born in 1889. The family were in the 1891 census in Glasgow, with the father recorded as a spirit shopman. I subsequently tracked Mary Heggie and young William to Detroit in the USA, and it seemed they emigrated around 1892. But where was Charlie? There were no death or census records here or in the USA, and he seemed to have simply vanished.
The breakthrough came in an entirely unexpected location, and it was thanks to a memorial advert placed by the good old Fremantle Lumpers' Union in the Western Australian newspaper: 'The members of the above Union are respectfully invited to follow the remains of their late comrade, Mr Charles Winton Heggie, of Wharf Street, Queen's Park, and formerly of Cottesloe, to the place of interment, the Presbyterian Cemetery, Karrakatta.' He had died in Perth, Australia, on 15 July 1925, and I soon found further death notices inserted by his wife - but not his first wife. It all became clear, Heggie had deserted Mary or perhaps the other way round, and both had emigrated in opposite directions to the other side of the world. Once in Australia, he remarried a woman called Emily Perkin in 1906, and started a second family.
All the remained was to find out what a Lumper is, or was. It's not hard to guess, they lump things around at the docks in Fremantle, the seaport next to Perth, and it seems they were quite a big thing in that part of the world. I've yet to find out what Heggie's exact role was with them, but the mystery of what happened to another Scotland international has finally been put to rest.
Heggie was a Rangers forward in the 1880s, not one of the greats but he had a fine eye for goal and was duly selected to play for Scotland against Ireland in March 1886. He was the outstanding player in a 7-2 victory, scoring no less than four of Scotland's goals - yet he was never capped again. He wound down his career at St Bernard's in Edinburgh, and was also an occasional referee, but there was no indication as to what happened to him after that. With an unusual name, it was little difficulty to confirm his date of birth (26 September 1862), a marriage in 1886 to Mary McIntosh, and a son William born in 1889. The family were in the 1891 census in Glasgow, with the father recorded as a spirit shopman. I subsequently tracked Mary Heggie and young William to Detroit in the USA, and it seemed they emigrated around 1892. But where was Charlie? There were no death or census records here or in the USA, and he seemed to have simply vanished.
The breakthrough came in an entirely unexpected location, and it was thanks to a memorial advert placed by the good old Fremantle Lumpers' Union in the Western Australian newspaper: 'The members of the above Union are respectfully invited to follow the remains of their late comrade, Mr Charles Winton Heggie, of Wharf Street, Queen's Park, and formerly of Cottesloe, to the place of interment, the Presbyterian Cemetery, Karrakatta.' He had died in Perth, Australia, on 15 July 1925, and I soon found further death notices inserted by his wife - but not his first wife. It all became clear, Heggie had deserted Mary or perhaps the other way round, and both had emigrated in opposite directions to the other side of the world. Once in Australia, he remarried a woman called Emily Perkin in 1906, and started a second family.
All the remained was to find out what a Lumper is, or was. It's not hard to guess, they lump things around at the docks in Fremantle, the seaport next to Perth, and it seems they were quite a big thing in that part of the world. I've yet to find out what Heggie's exact role was with them, but the mystery of what happened to another Scotland international has finally been put to rest.
- Published on
There was precious little Christmas spirit at the Scottish Football Association in 1888. Justice was meted out swiftly to two players from Third Lanark and Abercorn who traded blows on the pitch, and got a criminal record into the bargain.
It was a sorry end to an epic Scottish Cup clash between two of Scotland's strongest sides, Third Lanark and Abercorn, who met in the fifth round of the cup. Thirds won 5-4 on 24 November but the Paisley side protested to the SFA that the game had finished in darkness, and were granted a replay. On 8 December the sides drew 2-2, and a week later it was again 2-2. The tie therefore went to a fourth match, played at neutral Ibrox on 22 December. This time Thirds came out on top, winning 3-1, but the notable feature of the game came just before the end, described in the press as 'a somewhat unseemly incident':
Lochhead of the Volunteers and Buchanan of the Abercorn engaged in a stand-up fight, the result being one black eye in favour of the Third man. Buchanan expressed great annoyance at his 'facial decoration', remarking that it looked bad at this season of the year. For that little bit of by-play - which was very much appreciated by a portion of the crowd - both players were ordered off the field, and in all probability will be suspended by the Association on Tuesday evening.
Astonishingly enough, there was indeed an SFA meeting on Tuesday, Christmas Day, although 'there was a general regret that the members should have been called together on Christmas night, and an attempt was made to get through the business quickly'. A variety of business included the disciplinary issue of the cup-tie: Buchanan and Lochhead, who indulged in a 'free fight' last Saturday in the match, Abercorn v Third Lanark, were suspended for a month. The latter wrote apologising and, though the Association thanked him for his letter, they were sorry to come to the conclusion that he ought to be punished in the manner described.
That was not the end of their troubles, by any means. In a rare intervention by the courts into football business, the two players appeared in Govan Magistrates Court on 28 December: Robert Buchanan, residing in Greenock, and a member of the Paisley Abercorn Football Club, and Alexander Lochhead, a member of the Third Lanark Club, were charged at Govan with fighting with each other during a football match, which was witnessed by 5,000 persons. The Magistrate said the public went to see football and not fights, and fined Buchanan 2 guineas, or thirty days, and Lochhead 30s, or twenty days.
Presumably both players paid up rather than go to prison, but despite the shame and financial loss, it all ended well. Alex Lochhead (pictured above) was back in the Third Lanark side by the time they won the Scottish Cup in February 1889, defeating an upstart new club called Celtic in the final. And in April, having been forgiven by the SFA, he was capped for Scotland against Wales. Robert Buchanan also came good, and he too won a Scotland cap against Wales, scoring one of the goals in a 4-3 victory in 1891.
In these days when the SFA boasts of its Fast Track Tribunals to deal swiftly with players who step out of line, it is worth remembering that in the Victorian era their officials would happily give up their Christmas dinner to see that justice was done.
It was a sorry end to an epic Scottish Cup clash between two of Scotland's strongest sides, Third Lanark and Abercorn, who met in the fifth round of the cup. Thirds won 5-4 on 24 November but the Paisley side protested to the SFA that the game had finished in darkness, and were granted a replay. On 8 December the sides drew 2-2, and a week later it was again 2-2. The tie therefore went to a fourth match, played at neutral Ibrox on 22 December. This time Thirds came out on top, winning 3-1, but the notable feature of the game came just before the end, described in the press as 'a somewhat unseemly incident':
Lochhead of the Volunteers and Buchanan of the Abercorn engaged in a stand-up fight, the result being one black eye in favour of the Third man. Buchanan expressed great annoyance at his 'facial decoration', remarking that it looked bad at this season of the year. For that little bit of by-play - which was very much appreciated by a portion of the crowd - both players were ordered off the field, and in all probability will be suspended by the Association on Tuesday evening.
Astonishingly enough, there was indeed an SFA meeting on Tuesday, Christmas Day, although 'there was a general regret that the members should have been called together on Christmas night, and an attempt was made to get through the business quickly'. A variety of business included the disciplinary issue of the cup-tie: Buchanan and Lochhead, who indulged in a 'free fight' last Saturday in the match, Abercorn v Third Lanark, were suspended for a month. The latter wrote apologising and, though the Association thanked him for his letter, they were sorry to come to the conclusion that he ought to be punished in the manner described.
That was not the end of their troubles, by any means. In a rare intervention by the courts into football business, the two players appeared in Govan Magistrates Court on 28 December: Robert Buchanan, residing in Greenock, and a member of the Paisley Abercorn Football Club, and Alexander Lochhead, a member of the Third Lanark Club, were charged at Govan with fighting with each other during a football match, which was witnessed by 5,000 persons. The Magistrate said the public went to see football and not fights, and fined Buchanan 2 guineas, or thirty days, and Lochhead 30s, or twenty days.
Presumably both players paid up rather than go to prison, but despite the shame and financial loss, it all ended well. Alex Lochhead (pictured above) was back in the Third Lanark side by the time they won the Scottish Cup in February 1889, defeating an upstart new club called Celtic in the final. And in April, having been forgiven by the SFA, he was capped for Scotland against Wales. Robert Buchanan also came good, and he too won a Scotland cap against Wales, scoring one of the goals in a 4-3 victory in 1891.
In these days when the SFA boasts of its Fast Track Tribunals to deal swiftly with players who step out of line, it is worth remembering that in the Victorian era their officials would happily give up their Christmas dinner to see that justice was done.
- Published on
Ah, the good old days. This is a report on a local cup final between two of Renfrewshire's finest early sides, in April 1887:
Abercorn v Arthurlie - Disgraceful scenes. While this match was being played at Paisley on Saturday, through the violent charge of McCormick, Hamilton of the Arthurlie had to be carried unconscious off the field and play had to be stopped. As soon as play was resumed, there was a free fight between T. Johnstone and one of the Arthurlie backs, and the men had to be separated.
From a brilliant run taken part in by the Arthurlie's front lot, Seymour got a chance and put the first point for the Arthurlie. Later, McCormick scored the equalising point for the Abercorn. As soon as the ball was started, Allison rushed right along his wing, and registered the second point for the Abercorn. At this time, five of the players were limping with kicks received on the legs. Against this second goal the Arthurlie protested, claiming that the ball had not gone through. As the referee allowed the goal, the Arthurlie left the field, and scenes of great confusion followed.
The crowd broke into the field, free fights were general, and a rush made for the money boxes. Two boxes of money were carried away. Later when the policeman had got the crowd cleared away from the entrance to the main gate, it was found that not only had the greater part of the money been carried off, but that two of the money collectors - a young man from Thornliebank and a young man from Busby - had been seriously assaulted. One of them was rescued from a crowd of roughs in an exhausted condition, and had to be carried into the pavilion.
During this time free fights were taking place all over the field. The crowd refused to move until they got their money back, as the match had been stopped exactly a minute before half-time. Inside the pavilion were the two teams and a number of their supporters, and there angry words were also taking place. The principal officials and the Renfrewshire Association urged the two teams to reappear on the field to please the crowd. About six o'clock the two teams reappeared on the field the finish the game in a friendly manner, but neither would resume the cup-tie.
NB - playing in 'friendly' fashion, Abercorn scored three more goals and the final score was 5-1 for them. A few days later, the Renfrewshire FA decided that the rest of the match was, after all, going to count and promptly awarded the cup to Abercorn.
Abercorn v Arthurlie - Disgraceful scenes. While this match was being played at Paisley on Saturday, through the violent charge of McCormick, Hamilton of the Arthurlie had to be carried unconscious off the field and play had to be stopped. As soon as play was resumed, there was a free fight between T. Johnstone and one of the Arthurlie backs, and the men had to be separated.
From a brilliant run taken part in by the Arthurlie's front lot, Seymour got a chance and put the first point for the Arthurlie. Later, McCormick scored the equalising point for the Abercorn. As soon as the ball was started, Allison rushed right along his wing, and registered the second point for the Abercorn. At this time, five of the players were limping with kicks received on the legs. Against this second goal the Arthurlie protested, claiming that the ball had not gone through. As the referee allowed the goal, the Arthurlie left the field, and scenes of great confusion followed.
The crowd broke into the field, free fights were general, and a rush made for the money boxes. Two boxes of money were carried away. Later when the policeman had got the crowd cleared away from the entrance to the main gate, it was found that not only had the greater part of the money been carried off, but that two of the money collectors - a young man from Thornliebank and a young man from Busby - had been seriously assaulted. One of them was rescued from a crowd of roughs in an exhausted condition, and had to be carried into the pavilion.
During this time free fights were taking place all over the field. The crowd refused to move until they got their money back, as the match had been stopped exactly a minute before half-time. Inside the pavilion were the two teams and a number of their supporters, and there angry words were also taking place. The principal officials and the Renfrewshire Association urged the two teams to reappear on the field to please the crowd. About six o'clock the two teams reappeared on the field the finish the game in a friendly manner, but neither would resume the cup-tie.
NB - playing in 'friendly' fashion, Abercorn scored three more goals and the final score was 5-1 for them. A few days later, the Renfrewshire FA decided that the rest of the match was, after all, going to count and promptly awarded the cup to Abercorn.
Categories
- Aberdeen (1)
- Albion Rovers (1)
- Alloa (1)
- Arthur Kinnaird (3)
- Aston Villa (1)
- athletics (5)
- Australia (6)
- Ayrshire (8)
- Belgium (1)
- black heritage (18)
- Blackburn (1)
- boxing (1)
- Bridge of Allan (2)
- Cambridge (1)
- Canada (8)
- Celtic (1)
- collecting (2)
- cricket (10)
- curling (3)
- Darwen (5)
- Denmark (4)
- Dingwall (1)
- Dougray Scott (1)
- Doune (1)
- Dumbarton (1)
- Dunblane (10)
- Dundee (4)
- Dundee United (1)
- Edinburgh (28)
- England (15)
- Everton (1)
- FIFA (3)
- Film and TV (5)
- First World War (11)
- football (179)
- France (10)
- Germany (1)
- Glasgow (18)
- goal scoring (6)
- golf (1)
- gravestones (9)
- Grimsby (1)
- Hampden Park (5)
- heading (1)
- Heart of Midlothian (6)
- Helensburgh (1)
- Hibernian (2)
- hockey (2)
- Ice hockey (1)
- Italy (2)
- Juventus (1)
- Laws of the Game (8)
- Leith Athletic (1)
- lion taming (2)
- literature (8)
- Mexico (1)
- Newcastle United (1)
- Olympics (9)
- origins (63)
- Partick (5)
- Perthshire (2)
- photography (8)
- Poland (1)
- programmes (2)
- publications (25)
- Queen's Park (17)
- Rangers (5)
- record breaking (2)
- rowing (5)
- rugby (10)
- scandal (16)
- Scotland (103)
- South America (5)
- Spain (2)
- speedway (1)
- St Mirren (1)
- swimming (1)
- tennis (5)
- Third Lanark (6)
- Trophies (4)
- USA (4)
- women (6)
Archives
- September 2026 (1)
- August 2026 (2)
- July 2026 (1)
- June 2026 (1)
- March 2026 (1)
- December 2025 (1)
- November 2025 (3)
- October 2025 (1)
- August 2025 (1)
- June 2025 (1)
- May 2025 (3)
- April 2025 (1)
- March 2025 (1)
- February 2025 (1)
- January 2025 (2)
- December 2024 (1)
- October 2024 (2)
- September 2024 (1)
- July 2024 (1)
- April 2024 (2)
- February 2024 (1)
- June 2023 (1)
- February 2023 (1)
- January 2023 (1)
- December 2022 (1)
- November 2022 (2)
- September 2022 (1)
- July 2022 (1)
- June 2022 (1)
- May 2022 (1)
- March 2022 (1)
- February 2022 (3)
- January 2022 (1)
- December 2021 (1)
- November 2021 (1)
- October 2021 (1)
- September 2021 (1)
- August 2021 (1)
- July 2021 (4)
- June 2021 (1)
- May 2021 (2)
- April 2021 (1)
- March 2021 (1)
- January 2021 (1)
- December 2020 (1)
- November 2020 (1)
- October 2020 (5)
- September 2020 (2)
- August 2020 (1)
- July 2020 (1)
- June 2020 (1)
- May 2020 (1)
- April 2020 (2)
- March 2020 (2)
- January 2020 (1)
- December 2019 (1)
- October 2019 (1)
- September 2019 (1)
- August 2019 (2)
- July 2019 (1)
- June 2019 (1)
- May 2019 (2)
- March 2019 (1)
- January 2019 (3)
- November 2018 (1)
- October 2018 (2)
- September 2018 (2)
- August 2018 (1)
- July 2018 (1)
- June 2018 (1)
- May 2018 (3)
- April 2018 (1)
- March 2018 (1)
- February 2018 (1)
- January 2018 (1)
- December 2017 (1)
- November 2017 (1)
- October 2017 (1)
- September 2017 (2)
- August 2017 (1)
- June 2017 (3)
- May 2017 (3)
- March 2017 (2)
- February 2017 (2)
- January 2017 (2)
- October 2016 (3)
- September 2016 (1)
- August 2016 (1)
- July 2016 (1)
- June 2016 (1)
- May 2016 (2)
- April 2016 (1)
- March 2016 (2)
- February 2016 (1)
- January 2016 (1)
- December 2015 (1)
- November 2015 (1)
- October 2015 (2)
- September 2015 (2)
- August 2015 (2)
- July 2015 (2)
- May 2015 (1)
- April 2015 (1)
- March 2015 (1)
- February 2015 (1)
- December 2014 (3)
- November 2014 (3)
- October 2014 (4)
- September 2014 (4)
- August 2014 (2)
- July 2014 (4)
- June 2014 (2)
- May 2014 (5)
- April 2014 (2)
- March 2014 (2)
- February 2014 (3)
- January 2014 (3)
- December 2013 (3)
- November 2013 (3)
- October 2013 (4)
- September 2013 (3)
- August 2013 (3)
- July 2013 (4)
- May 2013 (3)
- April 2013 (2)
- March 2013 (5)
- February 2013 (1)
- January 2013 (3)
- December 2012 (2)
- November 2012 (5)
- October 2012 (2)
- September 2012 (4)
- August 2012 (3)
- July 2012 (4)
- June 2012 (4)
- May 2012 (1)
Author
All blog posts, unless stated, are written by Andy Mitchell.