SPORTS HISTORY BLOG
Over 250 articles on all aspects of Scottish sport
- Published on
John Hope's football rules of 1833 (National Records of Scotland)
Pictured above is the world's earliest known set of football rules, written by John Hope in Edinburgh in 1833 to guide the members of his Foot-Ball Club which had been established in 1824. This crucial document now resides in the National Records of Scotland, and is a priceless piece of footballing history.
It is worth examining why Hope felt it necessary to lay down the rules in writing, and what they implied for the players.
By 1833 the club had been going for nine years, it was buoyant and attracting new recruits from a variety of backgrounds and schools. Therefore many of the players may not have had the implicit understanding of how to play and how to behave that former High School boys would have had.
The club's membership records indicate that football games involved up to 40 men playing at the same time, wearing caps to distinguish sides. Their football was of a robust and healthy nature, played within a defined area on rough grass fields in summer and winter. All games were played within the club membership as there simply was no other club with which to play competitive matches.
Their football was clearly a competitive game with a code of behaviour to avoid serious injury - the members were young men who needed to be able to walk to work or study the next morning. Their game had progressed from the schoolboy pastime of the High School Yards, and Hope probably felt he needed to establish some guidelines. His rules therefore appear to mark a step on football's evolutionary path from its often violent origins in the folk games of a less sophisticated age to the more sanitised, codified form which emerged in the 1850s. Hope wrote in his own hand:
- Single soled shoes, no iron
- No tripping
- Ball to pass imaginary line
- A free kick if ball out of bounds
- Pushing is allowed. Holding not illegal
- Allow the ball to be lifted between fields
Underneath, he noted the attributes of the game:
Aff [affirmative] Fun, air, exercise
Neg [negative] No tripping
These rules are brief, and leave much to the imagination, but they are highly significant not just in what they say, but what they do not say. In many respects this is similar to the early editions of Rugby School's laws in the 1840s, which stated they were to be regarded 'rather as a set of decisions on certain disputed points in football, than as containing all the Laws of the Game, which are too well known to render any explanation necessary.'
The full story of the 1833 rules is told in The World's First Foot-Ball Club, on sale now
Rules three and four introduce the concept of a method of scoring. The game needed winners and losers so a goal (or 'hail') was scored when the ball passed over the 'imaginary line', and we know from the financial records that there were painted hail sticks which operated as goalposts. Similarly, to stop the play wandering off into the distance, this imaginary line extended right round the pitch; so, if the ball went beyond the agreed boundary it would be retrieved and kicked back into play.
Rule five is interesting as it permits an element of physical aggression, allowing players to push and hold their opponents (as rugby allows to this day within defined circumstances such as tackling and scrums). However, pushing and holding are a long way from the 'no holds barred' approach of traditional folk football.
The final rule is harder to analyse, particularly as this is the only rule that Hope redrafted. He crossed out some words and perhaps had difficulty in condensing accepted practice into a short sentence. It appears to mean that the only time the ball could be lifted, i.e. picked up or handled, was when it was out of play 'between fields'. If that interpretation is correct it confirms that this was a forerunner to the non-handling code that ultimately became association football.
While Hope's football rules are brief and open to interpretation, it has to be remembered he was the first to attempt the task. This was decades before the versions created by footballers at Cambridge (1848), Sheffield (1858), the Football Association (1863) and several prominent schools. He was a man ahead of his time.
The story of The World's First Foot-Ball Club is on sale now, price £11.99.
- Published on
Image courtesy the Argyll and Sutherland Highlanders' Museum
Engraved with a detailed action scene of soldiers in kilts challenging for a ball against students in ordinary outdoor clothes, on the other side it has the match details. This silver medal provides an indisputable record of a competitive game of football taking place, and is of exceptional historical value as the sport's first trophy, in the sense that it was a prize for the winners.
The first of these related to a momentous game played on 25 January 1851 'in presence of a vast multitude' in the Queen’s Park (next to Holyrood Palace). It was contested 20-a-side between the Edinburgh University Foot Ball Club and the 93rd Regiment of Foot (later to become the Argyll and Sutherland Highlanders), who were garrisoned at Edinburgh Castle. The reporter gushed: 'The students looked all confidence and appeared active, fine, athletic fellows. The Highlanders took their places coolly but with resolute determination, arranging themselves in a manner which displayed excellent training.'
The teams kicked off at half past two for the best of five games (goals), with ends changed each time a goal was scored, and two hours later the soldiers were declared the winners by a convincing 3-0 margin.
What made this contest particularly noteworthy is that the teams had agreed beforehand that the losers would present the winners with a medal – originally meant to be gold, but in the event only silver. It was commissioned from the silversmith James Mackay, whose son Robert had been a member of John Hope's Foot-Ball Club from 1824-26; he may have been able to advise his father on the design. This priceless object is now on display in the Argyll and Sutherland Highlanders' regimental museum in Stirling Castle.
The soldiers were no strangers to football. The previous month they had played a match at Spark's Cricket Ground in Grove Crescent, reported in the press, and that helped to provide clues to the identity of the winning captain. He was Lieutenant William Donald Macdonald, born in 1827 in Strathmartine, Angus and who joined the regiment in 1847 as Ensign. He had a much-decorated military career in the Crimea, China and the Indian Mutiny, rising to the rank of Lieutenant Colonel before he died of cholera in India in 1862.
William Donald Macdonald, the captain of the medal-winning team in 1851 (Edinburgh University Library)
While the medal match was important, the students were not done yet. A month later Bell's Life published a report headed 'University of Edinburgh Foot Ball Club’' of a 24-a-side match between 'the Scotch and English members composing this club'. I believe this is the first known example of a football match of any kind being played according to nationality.
The game started at two, the teams identified 'on the Scotch side by a green badge, and on the English by a red', and it was agreed that they would play for three hours. The Scots scored first with 'a lucky hit', then the English scored twice and were declared winners when five o'clock struck. The writer counted 500 spectators, named seven players from each side and two umpires, and gave us one of the most complete football reports of its day.
Although the participants were identified only by their surnames, it is possible to work out who some of them were. The English (Russell, Broadbent, Cobbold, Aldridge, Frost, Jones and Cousens) all appear to have been medical students, including William Henry Broadbent (1829-61) of Cheshire, Thomas Spencer Cobbold (1828-86) of Ipswich, and one of two Aldridge brothers from Hampshire.
The Scots (Nasmyth, Smyth, Currie, Frazer, Dickson, Bone and Christison) also featured future doctors such as John Barclay Nasmyth (1832-55) and David Christison (1830-1912), both of Edinburgh, and one of three Bone brothers from Barbados. The team also included James Currie (1828-86), a Divinity student, and Archibald Dickson (1829-95) of Hawick who was studying Law. The two umpires were probably Robert Paterson, a Law student from Ayrshire, and James Hood Wilson, later a Free Church minister.
The final report in Bell's Life that spring was of a match played on Leith Links on 21 March 1851, between 'the members of the Edinburgh University club and the gentlemen attending the Veterinary College'. It was won 2-0 by the former after two hours, and the writer noted that 'the arrangement of the forces from the University was decidedly superior, and throughout their play was of a much higher order. This is mainly attributable to the good practice the side has been in since the commencement of their season.'
He makes reference to a proposed match between the Universities of Edinburgh and Glasgow, 'the first time the rival clubs have competed together', but unfortunately no report of this match has been found, if indeed it took place.
Thanks to these anonymous articles in 1851, we know that Edinburgh University Football Club was organised, practised regularly and had a programme of fixtures. The soldiers of the 93rd also clearly enjoyed their sport and even after they left Edinburgh for a posting at Weedon Barracks in Northamptonshire they held Highland Games which concluded with a game of football.
Although there are no further accounts of the Edinburgh students playing football until the end of the decade, that may simply be due to a lack of newspaper coverage. The clear inference from all of this, notably the presentation of the first medal and the number of detailed reports, is that football was played more widely in the 1850s than is generally believed. Long before it was codified into the modern game, football was a popular pastime in Edinburgh.
Bell's Life report of the medal match in Edinburgh, published 2 February 1851
- Several schools held house championships, such as Rugby from 1850 and Harrow in 1853 but they did not award a trophy in the early years. Eton instituted their House Football Cup in 1860, while at Uppingham the Champion House Football Cup was inaugurated in 1864
- The first adult football club to award a silver cup was Sheffield FC, presented to William Prest in 1858 for winning the 100 yards sprint.
- The earliest adult football knock-out trophy was the Youdan Cup, competed for by Sheffield clubs in 1867.
- The oldest association football competition is the FA Cup, started in 1871/72, and the oldest surviving trophy is the Scottish FA Cup of 1874.
- Published on
Marjorie Langmuir in action for Scotland [from One Hundred Years of Scottish Hockey]
All this was done as an amateur, paying her own travel expenses while juggling the demands of a full time job. She was one of a generation of pioneering Scottish sportswomen who performed remarkable feats but received little recognition at the time and have since been largely forgotten. However, having discovered her story I nominated her for the inaugural Scottish Women in Sport Hall of Fame and I am delighted she was selected as one of the first inductees.
Born in Glasgow in 1905, Langmuir was one of five daughters educated at Hillhead High School where she developed her love of sport.
She was West of Scotland Junior Tennis Champion but it was in hockey that she first made her mark at national level. She was capped in 1923 as an 18-year-old student and by the time she returned to Hillhead in 1927 as a PE teacher, she was a fixture in the Scotland hockey team, playing in 36 consecutive internationals.
She also made quite a name for herself on the tennis courts and won the Scottish ladies doubles championship in 1926, while at badminton she first represented Scotland in 1930, going on to win eleven caps and twice won the Scottish mixed doubles championship.
Her hockey career was crowned in glory in 1933, when she captained the only Scotland women’s team ever to win in England. In fact, the 2-1 victory in front of 5,000 spectators at Merton Abbey was the only time Scotland defeated England, home or away, between 1909 and 1972. It was a sharp contrast to Marjory’s first game against England ten years earlier which ended in a 13-0 defeat. That autumn she led Scotland to a 5-4 victory over USA at Old Anniesland, her final match before retiring.
The Scotland team which beat England in 1933, captained by Marjorie Langmuir (front row centre) [Scottish Hockey]
Marjorie Langmuir
Born Glasgow, 20 January 1905 to Dr Robert Langmuir and Jessie Ritchie
Died Montreal, 17 March 1984.
* The only other Scottish athlete I can find who represented their country in three sports in the same year was Isabel Barr (later Newstead), who won Paralympic medals in 1984 at swimming, shooting and athletics. She has also been inducted in the Hall of Fame.
- Published on
Renton in 1888
They won the Scottish Cup in 1885 and again in 1888, defeating Cambuslang in the final with a record 6-1 scoreline. That victory prompted a challenge to the English FA Cup winners, West Bromwich Albion, and the match on 12 May was heavily marketed as the 'Championship of the World'. In torrential rain, Renton won 4-1 and basked in the glory of their champion status.
Robert Bradley and Douglas Gorman have written the full story of the World Championship match, how it came about. and who the key personalities were. You can read it in the attached article (click here).
The Illustrated Sporting and Dramatic News devoted a full page to the World Championship match, with pictures of all the players and also showing the sea of umbrellas over the spectators.
- Published on
BBC Scotland's animated figure in the Scottish Cup video
But who was the original footballer on the cup? The Scottish Cup was commissioned in 1874 by the fledgling Scottish FA, who asked Glasgow silversmiths George Edward & Sons to come up with a suitably grand trophy. No cost was spared and the final bill came to £56 12 shillings (which included a set of medals) Trouble was, association football was in its infancy at the time, and the designer needed some help to create a lifelike representation of a player to stand on top.
The inspiration for the figure was published in The Graphic after the first football international, played on 30 November 1872. One of the nine drawings by William Ralston shows a Scotland player steadfastly dribbling the ball while an English tackler is robustly pushed away by a teammate.
The design of the Scottish Cup is described in The Sportsman newspaper, 1 January 1874
Unfortunately, Ralston did not caption his drawings with names of the players - this one is simply titled 'Dribbling' - and there are insufficient contemporary photographs to make a comparison, so it may never be possible to identify specifically which one of the Scotland team has been immortalised.
The Scottish Cup (1874)
The FA Cup (1872)
Taking this theme further, I was surprised to find that this was not the only time that trophy designers took inspiration from printed sources.
Football at the Oval: England v Scotland in 1875
Detail from the East of Scotland Shield
Detail from the Scottish Juvenile Cup
I would love to know of any other early football trophies that have taken their inspiration from external sources.
- Published on
I recently met a footballer’s descendant who had a mystery: nobody knew what had happened to her grandfather, Johnny Dick.
Dick was famous in his day: the first man to play 250 games for Arsenal and a title-winning coach in Czechoslovakia and Belgium, but then he simply disappeared from view. A quick check of some websites confirmed that there were a lot of gaps in his life. I did some research and here, for the first time, is his full story.
The Woolwich Arsenal team for 1905-06, with John Dick (captain) in the centre of the front row
He must have shown some promise as in 1898 he was tempted to move to London where he signed for Woolwich Arsenal as a professional. It was the start of a lifetime’s journey in football. He remained at Arsenal until 1912, the year before the club relocated north of the Thames, and over those 14 years he played 266 league matches. He was with them as the club won promotion to the First Division in 1904, and despite being only five feet seven he was a dominant figure at centre half or right half.
He was club captain for several seasons, then in latter years was mainly with the reserves, where he first took up coaching. He was a natural for the role, and for example when a youthful Charles Buchan (later an England international) had his first trial for Arsenal, he was reassured by 'Johnny Dick, a grand Scotsman who put me at my ease before the start'.
Meanwhile, in 1899 Dick married a Woolwich girl, Annie Keard, whose brother Alexander was later an Arsenal official. His long stay at the club earned him two benefit matches, and the £100 he gained from the second of those gave him the wherewithal to open a tobacconist’s shop in Plumstead in 1909. But a life behind the counter was not to be.
Dick advertised in the Woolwich Gazette in 1909
Dick remained with DFC throughout the First World War, even though Prague was then in Austria-Hungary, effectively the 'enemy'. However, in the context of the Czech nationalist movement it was possible, like Madden, to live normally in the city without being interned. Known simply as 'Johnny', he continued to play occasionally, the last recorded time being in 1917 when he was 40.
When Czechoslovakia came into existence in 1919, Dick took up the reins at AC Sparta. He turned them into a team to be feared – earning them the nickname 'Iron Sparta' – and they won an unofficial European Championship in 1921.
As his family of four boys and two girls grew up in Prague they became fluent in Czech, which led to at least two of them working as British intelligence officers in the Second World War because of their linguistic abilities.
At the end of 1922 the local papers announced that Dick was returning home 'for family reasons' but in fact he went to Antwerp where he was appointed coach of Beerschot. His new club dominated Belgian football over the succeeding five years, winning four league championships.
The Dick family listed in Belgian immigration records in 1922
It was a shock to everyone in Prague when they heard that he had succumbed to stomach cancer, aged just 55, and the Prager Tagblatt wrote 'He enjoyed great popularity everywhere because of his humble nature, and his advice was always well received. The news of his sudden demise has caused great regret in sports circles.'
Although he died at his son’s house in Welling, just a couple of miles from his early football exploits in Woolwich, his death was unreported in the English press.
Johnny Dick deserves greater recognition for his exploits, first as a defining influence in leading Arsenal to the top flight for the first time, then bringing a string of major successes to clubs in Czechoslovakia and Belgium. He was a bright light in a generation of British coaches who taught football to the 'continentals' in the early twentieth century.
He was buried at St Michael, East Wickham, but sadly the headstone is no longer there. Perhaps a small memorial on the site would be a suitable legacy.
Born 29 January 1877 in Eaglesham, Renfrewshire.
Died 14 September 1932 in Welling, Kent.
Football career:
Airdrieonians 1897-98
Woolwich Arsenal 1898-1912
Deutscher FC, Prague 1912-19
AC Sparta, Prague 1919-22
Beerschot, Antwerp 1922-28
AC Sparta, Prague 1928-32
With thanks to contributors to the scottishleague.net forum, and also to the blogs at Scottish Comedy FC and the Arsenal History Society.
- Published on
The match has a significant place in sporting history as it was the first football contest, of any code, between a British team and one from another country.
This programme was sold last year for £15,000 by Graham Budd Auctions in London. His catalogue entry commented that 'the visiting team would have influenced the match to be played as faithfully as possible to Association Rules, as first codified and published by the Football Association in England in 1863.'
In fact, even though it was eleven-a-side and a kicking rather than carrying game, the rules were a kind of soccer hybrid which had been agreed two months earlier between representatives of Yale, Columbia, Princeton and Rutgers. They specified 20-a-side games, with goals 25 feet wide and a pitch 400 feet long, while the ball was a No 6 (the Football Association specified goals 8 yards wide, and a pitch up to 200 yards long, with a No 5 ball). The method of restarting the game after a foul or going out of play was bizarre: ‘the player so offending shall throw the ball perpendicularly into the air to a height of at least 12 feet and the ball shall not be in play until it has touched the ground.’
One of the Yale players, Clarence Deming, gave an account of the match in his book Yale Yesterdays, published in 1915: 'A number of young Englishmen, graduates of Eton, in business or traveling in this country, after seeing one of the intercollegiate games at Hamilton Park, proposed a game between Yale and old Etonians in the United States. The idea was welcomed at Yale, and after considerable discussion, the Yale rules were accepted with 'peanutting' left out, teams of eleven, and the match to be won or lost on actual results of games.'
This comment is important, as it confirms that Yale rules were applied, albeit with the traditional Eton number of eleven players. The term 'peanutting' is slang for offside.
Teams for Yale v Eton on 6 December 1873 (Graham Budd Auctions)
Deming described the contrasting tactics: Eton massed behind the ball and tried to dribble it forward down the centre of the field, while Yale played the ball down the wings to create space. In the event, the weather had a major part in deciding the result, as all three goals in a 2-1 victory for Yale were scored with a gale at their backs; the sides changed ends after each goal. It might have lasted longer but the Etonians had to catch a train back to New York.
Bell's Life, 3 January 1874 (British Newspaper Archive)
The Eton players (two did not attend the school) were listed by their initials, and it appears that a couple of errors crept in. I have researched their identities, and here is the full team:
George Cunard Allen (1848-1902), team captain. Eton 1860-66, now living in New York, partner in Bush & Jevons, merchants. Son of Major RSA Allen of Bath.
Philip Allen (1853-1903). Eton 1867-71. In business in New York, brother of above.
Gerald William (listed as JW) Balfour (1853-1945). Eton 1866-71, then Trinity College, Cambridge. MP 1885-1906, Chief Secretary for Ireland. Younger brother of AJ Balfour, son of JM Balfour of Whittinghame, East Lothian.
Constantine William Benson (1852-1905). Eton 1864-71 (Wall Eleven & Field Eleven), then Trinity College, Cambridge (Rowing blue). Partner in CW Benson, Bankers of Minnesota. Son of R Benson, merchant banker of London.
Ernest Chaplin (1849-1930). Harrow 1862-67, 'one of the best all round athletes'. Married Delene Morton in January 1874 in New York.
Edmund Smith Hanbury (1850-1913). Eton 1864-69 then Christ Church, Oxford. Son of RC Hanbury MP of Poles, Herts.
Robert Mure McKerrell (1846-1912). Eton 1859-63 then Trinity College, Cambridge. Of Hillhouse, Ayrshire and later Murrayfield, Edinburgh. Prison Commissioner for Scotland. A patron of St Mirren FC in the 1890s.
Hon Henry Romilly (1845-1886). Eton 1857-62 then Trinity College, Cambridge. Partner in Alfred Booth & Co, based in New York. Son of Lord Romilly, Master of the Rolls.
Robert Russell (1849-1876). Eton 1862-68 (Wall Eleven & Field Eleven), then Christ Church, Oxford. Accidentally killed in Abyssinia on a hunting expedition. Son of Captain R Russell of Bedale.
Viscount Tarbat (1852-93). Privately educated. Full name Francis Mackenzie Leveson-Gower, second son of the Duke of Sutherland. He was on a tour of USA 1873-74. Seaforth Highlanders.
Henry Meysey Meysey-Thompson (1845-1929). Eton 1858-64 (Cricket Eleven and athletics champion), then Trinity College, Cambridge (athletics blue). MP from 1880, intermittently. From 1905, he was Lord Knaresborough of Kirby Hall, Yorkshire. His brothers Albert and Charles won the FA Cup with Wanderers.
Further reading:
The Professional Football Researchers Association has a wide range of articles, notably No Christian End! about the early years of American college football and the evolving rules debate:
http://www.profootballresearchers.org/pfra-articles.htm
For more about early college programmes, see the Collectable Ivy website, which specializes in vintage American college football, and in particular their blogs about early programs:
https://collectableivy.wordpress.com/category/early-football-programs/
Graham Budd Auctions:
www.grahambuddauctions.co.uk
- Published on
I have written before about his exploits, but what really brings a story to life is a family connection. Therefore I was delighted to be contacted by his great grandson Colin Taylor, who recently sent me these fantastic photos. This is the gold medal won when Joe captained Queen's Park to victory in the 1876 cup final, when Third Lanark were beaten in a replay.
Although this is not the oldest winner's medal in existence - the Scottish Football Museum has JJ Thomson's silver medal from 1874 - it does bear witness to the rapid growth of the game in Scotland, being made of gold and with the Scottish FA's new crest engraved on the front.
Joe Taylor in 1886 (courtesy Colin Taylor)
Gold watch presented to Joseph Taylor on the occasion of his wedding (courtesy Colin Taylor)
Notably, he travelled to London in March 1872 to play against Wanderers in the FA Cup semi-final, when Queen's Park shocked the football establishment by holding the hosts to a 0-0 draw. He played in the first international later that year, and went on to captain Scotland against England in 1875 and 1876, in addition to his club successes.
He gave up playing football in 1877 but remained closely involved with Queen's Park and was elected club President for 1878/79. He worked as a clerk for a drapery wholesaler and all was well until 1885 when he was struck down by the first signs of tuberculosis. He went to New Zealand for six months to try and clear his lungs with sea air, which worked for a time but in the days before antibiotics it was really only a matter of time before he succumbed. He died in October 1888 at his home in Victoria Terrace, close to Hampden Park, and laid to rest in Cathcart Cemetery, where you can still see his memorial.
After he died, Joe Taylor's obituary in the Glasgow Herald left no doubts about his standing: 'To the older school of players and followers of the game, that gentleman was known as the embodiment of everything that was best, purest and most manly in a football player.'
He was held in such high regard that Queen’s Park played a benefit match against Third Lanark on 5 January 1889, attracting around 7,000 spectators to Hampden and raising over £100. The club then added £50 to the fund for his family, an enormous sum which assured his sons' future (and meant they would never have to sell his medals).
The memorial to Joseph Taylor in Cathcart Cemetery
You can read the stories of all the early internationalists in my book First Elevens.
UPDATE - APRIL 2024
Joseph Taylor's grave at Cathcart Cemetery has been restored. Check out the story: https://www.scottishsporthistory.com/sports-history-news-and-blog/scottish-football-pioneer-joseph-taylors-grave-restored
- Published on
The display panels are portable so they can be taken to schools, and should be a great tool for generating a wider interest and appreciation of how Ross County got to where they are now. Formed as late as 1929 as the northernmost club in the Highland League, their rise in recent years to the top level of Scottish football is nothing short of extraordinary.
Just thirty years ago, in 1987, the club finished bottom of the Highland League in the midst of a cash crisis, yet it bounced back to win two titles in the early 90s and was then elected to the Scottish League in 1994. Steady progress through the divisions saw them reach the Premier Division in 2012, and then win their first national trophy, the Scottish League Cup, in 2016.
There is a risk that the younger generation might take this level of success for granted, so this kind of exhibition is a great way of reminding (or introducing) people of the area's footballing roots.
There is also a celebration of the wider football heritage of the Highlands, and one story that particularly intrigues me is the little known fact that Scotland's first football cup was contested in Tain, four years before our oldest national trophy, the Scottish Cup.
In June 1870, a local businessman, Thomas Beales Snowie, paid £5 for a silver cup to be awarded to the winners of a match between Tain Ragged School and Inverness Reformatory School. There was a joint team photo before the match, which was won by Inverness. They were presented with the cup while the Tain boys were presented with a football to practise with. However, although there were proposals for a rematch the following year it was a one-off.
This historic trophy's whereabouts are now unknown, and it would be a fantastic find it it could be located. Hopefully this exhibition will inspire a local historian to find out what happened to it.
Ross County take on Hibs at the Global Energy Stadium
With thanks to Chris Ross of the Ross County Foundation for the invitation to the launch and the match.
- Published on
Alexander Crombie (centre) was first captain of Edinburgh Academical Football Club in 1858. This image comes from the club's 50th anniversary dinner menu.
What intrigued me was, why had the Crombies been in Durham in the first place? The Crombie family had been living in Edinburgh for over ten years by this time.
In fact, it was all due to a shameless charlatan of a schoolteacher - a fascinating example of how unconnected events can lead to an unexpected outcome.
Alexander and Francis were born in 1836 and 1838 respectively at Thornton Castle, the family seat, then lived in Kent with their lawyer father (also called Alexander) before they all settled in Edinburgh New Town around 1843.
In 1847, when they were aged 10 and 9, both boys went to Merchiston Castle School on the outskirts of Edinburgh. They probably played football here, as the school had a playing field directly opposite. But more importantly they were taught by a charismatic teacher called Edward Humphreys.
In 1850, Humphreys left Merchiston to set up his own private school, Salisbury House in Newington, and the Crombie boys followed him there. They boarded, despite the family home being so close, and did well, judging by the number of prizes they won.
Then early in 1852, out of the blue, Humphreys was appointed as headmaster of Cheltenham Grammar School (now known as Pate's). With little regard for his existing pupils, he closed his school in Edinburgh immediately, and took up his new post.
This left parents and pupils in the lurch, and Alexander Crombie senior had to find a new school for his two boys in a hurry. For whatever reason, he chose Durham and they enrolled there in March 1852.
Durham Grammar had recently taken up Rugby rules for school football, and therefore the brothers learned to play football that way. Alexander stayed until December 1853, while Francis remained until the autumn of 1854 when he came home to complete his education at Edinburgh Academy.
The Laws of Football printed in 1851 at Rugby School, probably the same booklet that Francis Crombie brought to Edinburgh Academy in 1854. (This copy was sold at auction for £13,000 in 2016)
By the end of the decade, the Rugby code had gained widespread popularity. Not until 1867 was the non-handling association football taken up by Queen’s Park in Glasgow, and the association game did not reach Edinburgh until 1873.
Meanwhile, elder brother Alexander matriculated at Edinburgh University to study Law, and while there he helped to found the Academical Football Club early in 1858, becoming its first captain.
The Crombie brothers are rightly credited with introducing Rugby football to Scotland, but what is particularly interesting is the back story to Mr Humphreys, the disappearing teacher. He was a fake academic and a financial fraud.
Edward Rupert Humphreys was born in Dublin in 1820, and went to Heversham School in Westmorland before matriculating at Cambridge University in 1836 to study medicine. He did not graduate and in 1838 was listed as an insolvent debtor.
He found a teaching post near Manchester, where he married in 1841, but two years later was declared insolvent for a second time. His response was to run away and somehow he landed a job as head master of a school on Prince Edward Island, in what is now Canada.
In four years there, during which his first wife died and he remarried, Humphreys did such a good job at reinventing himself that in 1848 he was able to return to Britain as Head Classical and English master at Merchiston Castle School in Edinburgh. What is more, he acquired credibility by writing textbooks, becoming a Fellow of the Educational Institute of Scotland, and crowned it all in 1850 by persuading both Edinburgh and Aberdeen Universities to give him honorary degrees.
What they based their decisions on is not recorded but he could now legitimately describe himself as Reverend Dr Humphreys LLD. He was, to all intents and purposes, an outstanding teacher and scholar, and on that basis, he left Merchiston in 1850 and set up his own school across the city in Salisbury Place.
Edward Humphreys
However, although the school promised much it seems to have struggled as there were constant adverts in the local papers for new recruits. Hence when Cheltenham Grammar School advertised for a new head, Humphreys had no qualms about applying and abandoning his own school in the middle of the session.
Cheltenham had been flagging for years and in 1852 he set about restoring the school’s fortunes with gusto. He introduced science to the curriculum – for which he was personally thanked by Prince Albert – increased the school roll, was popular with parents and governors, and held in such high regard that even when he was successfully prosecuted for flogging a boy, he was applauded on his return to school.
However, he borrowed heavily and ran up extensive debts, reported to have reached £26,000. In 1859, for the third time, he was declared insolvent in the London Gazette and his response, yet again, was to disappear across the Atlantic. If that was not bad enough, he scandalised the town by doing so with the wife of one of the school governors (who was also one of his debtors), each of them abandoning a large family. The newspapers were full of the affair, and although a tearful Emily Comyn came home a couple of months later, Humphreys never returned. He would have faced a substantial claim for damages had he done so.
Yet, astonishingly, he reinvented himself in Boston where carried on teaching as if nothing had happened. In those pre-internet days, it is not as if anyone could google him. He was appointed Principal of South End Collegiate School, became a naturalised American, and even persuaded his wife Margaret and six children to join him there. Perhaps anything was better than the scorn they faced in Cheltenham.
Humphreys escaped scandal to such an extent that when he died in 1893 the Gloucester Journal described the former headmaster as ‘a distinguished classical scholar’ without any reference to his murky past. Humphreys was undoubtedly a charlatan, but without his shameless behaviour the history of Scottish sport might have been very different.
As a postscript, the son named after the rugby-playing family, Alexander Crombie Humphreys (1851-1927), went on to have a legitimately brilliant academic career, rising to be president of the Stevens Institute of Technology in New Jersey, and is known as the father of engineering economics.
Categories
- Aberdeen (1)
- Albion Rovers (1)
- Alloa (1)
- Arthur Kinnaird (3)
- Aston Villa (1)
- athletics (5)
- Australia (6)
- Ayrshire (8)
- Belgium (1)
- black heritage (18)
- Blackburn (1)
- boxing (1)
- Bridge of Allan (2)
- Cambridge (1)
- Canada (8)
- Celtic (1)
- collecting (2)
- cricket (10)
- curling (3)
- Darwen (5)
- Denmark (4)
- Dingwall (1)
- Dougray Scott (1)
- Doune (1)
- Dumbarton (1)
- Dunblane (10)
- Dundee (4)
- Dundee United (1)
- Edinburgh (28)
- England (15)
- Everton (1)
- FIFA (3)
- Film and TV (5)
- First World War (11)
- football (179)
- France (10)
- Germany (1)
- Glasgow (18)
- goal scoring (6)
- golf (1)
- gravestones (9)
- Grimsby (1)
- Hampden Park (5)
- heading (1)
- Heart of Midlothian (7)
- Helensburgh (1)
- Hibernian (3)
- hockey (2)
- Ice hockey (1)
- Italy (2)
- Juventus (1)
- Laws of the Game (8)
- Leith Athletic (1)
- lion taming (2)
- literature (8)
- Mexico (1)
- Newcastle United (1)
- Olympics (9)
- origins (63)
- Partick (5)
- Perthshire (2)
- photography (8)
- Poland (1)
- programmes (2)
- publications (25)
- Queen's Park (17)
- Rangers (5)
- record breaking (2)
- rowing (5)
- rugby (10)
- scandal (16)
- Scotland (103)
- South America (5)
- Spain (2)
- speedway (1)
- St Mirren (1)
- swimming (1)
- tennis (5)
- Third Lanark (6)
- Trophies (4)
- USA (4)
- women (6)
Archives
- September 2026 (1)
- August 2026 (2)
- July 2026 (1)
- June 2026 (1)
- March 2026 (1)
- December 2025 (1)
- November 2025 (3)
- October 2025 (1)
- August 2025 (1)
- June 2025 (1)
- May 2025 (3)
- April 2025 (1)
- March 2025 (1)
- February 2025 (1)
- January 2025 (2)
- December 2024 (1)
- October 2024 (2)
- September 2024 (1)
- July 2024 (1)
- April 2024 (2)
- February 2024 (1)
- June 2023 (1)
- February 2023 (1)
- January 2023 (1)
- December 2022 (1)
- November 2022 (2)
- September 2022 (1)
- July 2022 (1)
- June 2022 (1)
- May 2022 (1)
- March 2022 (1)
- February 2022 (3)
- January 2022 (1)
- December 2021 (1)
- November 2021 (1)
- October 2021 (1)
- September 2021 (1)
- August 2021 (1)
- July 2021 (4)
- June 2021 (1)
- May 2021 (2)
- April 2021 (1)
- March 2021 (1)
- January 2021 (1)
- December 2020 (1)
- November 2020 (1)
- October 2020 (5)
- September 2020 (2)
- August 2020 (1)
- July 2020 (1)
- June 2020 (1)
- May 2020 (1)
- April 2020 (2)
- March 2020 (2)
- January 2020 (1)
- December 2019 (1)
- October 2019 (1)
- September 2019 (1)
- August 2019 (2)
- July 2019 (1)
- June 2019 (1)
- May 2019 (2)
- March 2019 (1)
- January 2019 (3)
- November 2018 (1)
- October 2018 (2)
- September 2018 (2)
- August 2018 (1)
- July 2018 (1)
- June 2018 (1)
- May 2018 (3)
- April 2018 (1)
- March 2018 (1)
- February 2018 (1)
- January 2018 (1)
- December 2017 (1)
- November 2017 (1)
- October 2017 (1)
- September 2017 (2)
- August 2017 (1)
- June 2017 (3)
- May 2017 (3)
- March 2017 (2)
- February 2017 (2)
- January 2017 (2)
- October 2016 (3)
- September 2016 (1)
- August 2016 (1)
- July 2016 (1)
- June 2016 (1)
- May 2016 (2)
- April 2016 (1)
- March 2016 (2)
- February 2016 (1)
- January 2016 (1)
- December 2015 (1)
- November 2015 (1)
- October 2015 (2)
- September 2015 (2)
- August 2015 (2)
- July 2015 (2)
- May 2015 (1)
- April 2015 (1)
- March 2015 (1)
- February 2015 (1)
- December 2014 (3)
- November 2014 (3)
- October 2014 (4)
- September 2014 (4)
- August 2014 (2)
- July 2014 (4)
- June 2014 (2)
- May 2014 (5)
- April 2014 (2)
- March 2014 (2)
- February 2014 (3)
- January 2014 (3)
- December 2013 (3)
- November 2013 (3)
- October 2013 (4)
- September 2013 (3)
- August 2013 (3)
- July 2013 (4)
- May 2013 (3)
- April 2013 (2)
- March 2013 (5)
- February 2013 (1)
- January 2013 (3)
- December 2012 (2)
- November 2012 (5)
- October 2012 (2)
- September 2012 (4)
- August 2012 (3)
- July 2012 (4)
- June 2012 (4)
- May 2012 (1)
Author
All blog posts, unless stated, are written by Andy Mitchell.