Image description

SPORTS HISTORY BLOG

Over 250 articles on all aspects of Scottish sport

Image description
Published on
Picture
I was delighted to find a ship manifest on ancestry.com for the first overseas tour by a Scottish football select. Clubs had travelled abroad since the 1890s, but the Scottish FA had held back from international contact. Then, in 1921, Third Lanark were given permission by the SFA to play a series of matches in Canada and USA that summer, and instead of restricting it to club players it was open to a wide range of good quality Scots, some of them internationals.
   They played 25 matches in two months, travelling from coast to coast, winning the first 24 but ending up with a draw against Fall River. Full details can be found here. The US Football Association presented the tourists with an attractive trophy (pictured) which has the SFA crest as well as the Third Lanark badge, either side of the US logo.
   The players sailed out on the Cunard liner Cameronia, leaving Liverpool on 11 May 1921, and the passenger list (below) is full of interesting detail about the players, some of whom gave their profession as footballer, while others gave their 'day job' such as publican or joiner.
   With a bit more digging, I've also found similar lists for the first 'official' SFA tours across the Atlantic, in 1927 and 1935, as well as various club lists including Third Lanark's venture to South American in 1923. These are great examples of the kind of material that is now available to historians after many years being hidden from view.
Picture
Picture
Published on
Picture

With Scotland due to travel to Wembley in August as part of the Football Association's 150th birthday celebrations, it is worth marking the anniversary of the first time our national team headed for London.
   On 8 March 1873, 140 years ago today, Queen's Park FC selected the team as the Scottish FA had still not been formed (that would come just a week later). There was only enough money in the kitty to pay the rail fares for seven players and an umpire, so four more had to be recruited locally. One of them, Robert Smith, was an obvious choice as he was a founding member of Queen's Park and had moved to London; he had also played in the first game in November. The others were John Blackburn and Henry Renny-Tailyour of the Royal Engineers - the latter already having played for Scotland at rugby - and Arthur Kinnaird, a young aristocratic banker from a Scottish family.
   The combination was not a great success, with the newcomers not familiar with Queen's Park's passing style, and England won the game 4-2. The Scots learned their lesson and not until 1896 would they again select any players based in England. It was largely a period of complete domination for Scotland, and England only won one of the next 14 matches between the nations.

Published on
I've spent a bit of time recently digitising early football texts, and will continue to upload more to this website from time to time, posted on the publications page. 
   To start with, these rare histories of Ayr FC and Kilmarnock FC are now available online to fellow historians for the first time.
   The Ayr booklet was produced in 1901, for a fund-raising bazaar - so financial difficulties are nothing new for Scottish football clubs. In this instance, the club had overspent on installing a cycle track and had to raise over £500 to clear the debt. At that time, Ayr (which merged with Ayr Parkhouse in 1910 to become Ayr United) was a multi-sports club, so football lived alongside athletics, cycling and tug of war. In an obscure coincidence of football history, the bazaar was opened by Sir William Arrol, the local MP, whose main claim to fame was the construction of the Forth Bridge; his cousin Mary Arrol had married Scotland's first football captain, Robert Gardner, who died in 1887 while working on ... the Forth Bridge.
   The Kilmarnock history is more straightforward, having been issued to commemorate the club's jubilee in 1919.
   To read either text, just click on the front cover images or visit my Sporting Anthology.
Published on
Picture
I came across this great caricature from 1877 in the Bailie, a Glasgow magazine which profiled prominent and influential citizens each week. It shows William Dick, who was at that time the secretary of the Scottish Football Association. He was not in the top rank of players, but set a high standard as an administrator before his early death aged just 29. See my earlier post [click on link] for pictures of his magnificent memorial in Glasgow Necropolis.
   It set me trawling through the volumes of the Bailie in Glasgow's Mitchell Library, to see which other football personalities were featured. There were not many, and no more until 1883 when 23 players were pictured as 'Football Favourites', a print I would dearly love to obtain. The Scotland national team was shown in 1886, SFA president Crerar a couple of years later, and SFA secretary JK McDowall in 1895.

Published on
Picture
One of the problems I find when researching Scotland internationals is that quite often their details don't match previously published material. Sometimes this means a birth is a year out, a Mac becomes a Mc, but occasionally a name changes completely.
   One such case was resolved this week when I was looking for the background to Tommy McInally, a Celtic star forward of the 1920s who also had spells at Third Lanark, Sunderland and a few other clubs. He won two caps in 1926, against Ireland and Wales. Known as a maverick who delighted the fans, he died of alcoholism on 29 December 1955. There were obituaries in the press, and an inscription on his grave at St Conval's Cemetery in Barrhead. But if you check the death registers, Thomas Bruce McInally, as the reference books call him, is nowhere to be seen.
   However, there was indeed a McInally who died that day, but his first name was Bernard. Death certificates give the names of parents, and from there it was simple enough to find the birth certificate of Bernard McInally, born in Main Street, Barrhead on 18 December 1899 to Francis McInally and Anne (maiden name Slaven). By the time of the 1901 census the boy was recorded as Thomas, the youngest of eight children including his older brother Arthur, who also went on to play for Celtic. And, for whatever reasons, he was known throughout his life as Tommy until that final note of his death reverted to his 'official' name.
Published on
Picture
I'm currently doing a lot of research into early Scotland international footballers, and have invested in a membership of ancestry.com as well as using a variety of other online sources. It's a long slog, following clues and cross-checking details, but I'm making good progress.
   Every now and then I find something that really stands out, and I was particularly taken by the above census return from a household in Liverpool in 1891. Staying with a Mrs Hughes, a widow, at 26 Coniston Street are six young men, all from Scotland, and all described as 'labourers'. But that masks their true vocation: they are all players for Everton Football Club, who would win the Football League championship in 1890/91; three of them were good enough to play for Scotland.  The players are Duncan McLean, Daniel Doyle, James A McMillan (the three internationalists), Daniel Kirkwood, Alexander Brady and Patrick Gordon.  Dan Doyle is perhaps the most famous of them, as after he captained Everton that season to their league title, he moved to Celtic where he won a further four league championships and nine Scotland caps.
   More satisfying for me was that this entry led me to other genealogical records which enabled me to pinpoint McLean and McMillan, two Scotland players who had previously been utterly elusive. Duncan McLean was born on 20 January 1868 in Renton, and died there on 17 November 1941. James Andrew McMillan was born in Bonhill on 11 April 1869, and died in Bootle on 20 February 1937.
   A similar discovery in the city of Liverpool which helped my research was from 1911. Two young Scots, described helpfully as professional footballers with Liverpool FC, are boarding with a tobacconist called William P Dunlop in Walton Breck Road, right outside Anfield. The players are John McConnell and Donald McKinley, and while the former returned north after two seasons, the latter became a Liverpool legend staying for almost two decades, winning two Scotland caps into the bargain. What makes the entry really interesting, however, is the tobacconist.
   William Dunlop had also played for Scotland during  a great Liverpool career, having joined the club in 1894 following spells with various Scottish clubs including Kilmarnock and Abercorn. His age (37) and middle initial (P) did not fit with the usual identification of him as born in 1871 with a middle name of Theodore. A bit of investigation confirmed that he was actually William Peden Dunlop, born in Hurlford on 11 August 1874. He died in Stanhope, County Durham, on 28 November 1941.
Published on
Picture

At a time of discussion about the future shape of league football in Scotland, and even the possibility of a pyramid to open up the lower reaches to ambitious smaller clubs, I was delighted to come across some vintage material relating to Helensburgh FC.   This douce west coast resort once hosted a league team, when the Scottish League tried on a previous occasion to expand its reach. For three seasons in the mid 1920s, there were three full divisions in the League, with an extraordinary total of 56 clubs. Among them was Helensburgh, who actually won Division Three in its final season, 1925/26, before financial imperatives saw the end of the experiment. They played at Ardencaple Park in the town, and thanks to the Helensburgh Heritage Trust's photo archive this rare image of the football ground can be seen along with a host of other local sporting photos. The Heritage Trust also has a good history of the football club in pdf format.    As websites go, this is an excellent example of how Scottish sporting heritage can be preserved and presented, as an integral part of a town's essential history.

Published on
Image description
There was precious little Christmas spirit at the Scottish Football Association in 1888. Justice was meted out swiftly to two players from Third Lanark and Abercorn who traded blows on the pitch, and got a criminal record into the bargain.
   It was a sorry end to an epic Scottish Cup clash between two of Scotland's strongest sides, Third Lanark and Abercorn, who met in the fifth round of the cup. Thirds won 5-4 on 24 November but the Paisley side protested to the SFA that the game had finished in darkness, and were granted a replay. On 8 December the sides drew 2-2, and a week later it was again 2-2. The tie therefore went to a fourth match, played at neutral Ibrox on 22 December. This time Thirds came out on top, winning 3-1, but the notable feature of the game came just before the end, described in the press as 'a somewhat unseemly incident':
   Lochhead of the Volunteers and Buchanan of the Abercorn engaged in a stand-up fight, the result being one black eye in favour of the Third man. Buchanan expressed great annoyance at his 'facial decoration', remarking that it looked bad at this season of the year. For that little bit of by-play - which was very much appreciated by a portion of the crowd - both players were ordered off the field, and in all probability will be suspended by the Association on Tuesday evening.
   Astonishingly enough, there was indeed an SFA meeting on Tuesday, Christmas Day, although 'there was a general regret that the members should have been called together on Christmas night, and an attempt was made to get through the business quickly'. A variety of business included the disciplinary issue of the cup-tie: Buchanan and Lochhead, who indulged in a 'free fight' last Saturday in the match, Abercorn v Third Lanark, were suspended for a month. The latter wrote apologising and, though the Association thanked him for his letter, they were sorry to come to the conclusion that he ought to be punished in the manner described.
  That was not the end of their troubles, by any means. In a rare intervention by the courts into football business, the two players appeared in Govan Magistrates Court on 28 December: Robert Buchanan, residing in Greenock, and a member of the Paisley Abercorn Football Club, and Alexander Lochhead, a member of the Third Lanark Club, were charged at Govan with fighting with each other during a football match, which was witnessed by 5,000 persons. The Magistrate said the public went to see football and not fights, and fined Buchanan 2 guineas, or thirty days, and Lochhead 30s, or twenty days.
   Presumably both players paid up rather than go to prison, but despite the shame and financial loss, it all ended well. Alex Lochhead (pictured above) was back in the Third Lanark side by the time they won the Scottish Cup in February 1889, defeating an upstart new club called Celtic in the final. And in April, having been forgiven by the SFA, he was capped for Scotland against Wales. Robert Buchanan also came good, and he too won a Scotland cap against Wales, scoring one of the goals in a 4-3 victory in 1891.
   In these days when the SFA boasts of its Fast Track Tribunals to deal swiftly with players who step out of line, it is worth remembering that in the Victorian era their officials would happily give up their Christmas dinner to see that justice was done.
Published on
Image description
For the third instalment of my commemoration of that game in 1872, I take a look at the Scots eleven who faced the English, 140 years ago today. Captained by Robert Gardner (pictured left), they were relative novices at the game, as Queen's Park was only founded five years earlier, yet their innovative style of passing play was good enough to hold the English to a draw. Not only that, they continued to develop the style and before the end of the decade they were almost unstoppable, and in 1878 beat England 7-2 and Wales 9-0. 
   You can read more about the players in my book, First Elevens, which puts right many of the myths which have grown up around them. Did you know that as many of them were born in Aberdeen as in Glasgow (three in each)? It's a common complaint of mine, but don't believe a word you read about them on Wikipedia.
  • Robert Gardner: pushy and opinionated, yet utterly dedicated to football, he stormed out of Queen's Park in 1874 to join nearby rivals Clydesdale. Elected president of the Scottish FA in 1877, he died in 1887 while working on the Forth Bridge project.
  • William Ker: son of a famous physicist (look up the Kerr Effect), he emigrated a year after the international and married a cousin of telephone inventor Alexander Graham Bell.
  • Joseph Taylor: a talented athlete from Dunoon, he became a Queen's Park stalwart and was club president, but left a widow and four sons when he died of tuberculosis in 1888.
  • James John Thomson: born in Annan, he captained Queen's Park to victory in the first Scottish Cup of 1874, but then went south and made a fortune in the meat industry.
  • James Smith: older brother of Robert, son of the Earl of Fife's head gardener, and founder of Queen's Park, he had moved to London in 1871. Died young of a stroke in 1876.
  • Robert Smith: educated at Fordyce Academy, he was also working in London and would soon emigrate to America where he became a prominent politician and newspaper proprietor in Wyoming.
  • James Biggar Weir: a joiner to trade, he was a Queen's Park regular for a decade before emigrating to Australia, where he died at a remote outback camp. His middle name is often quoted as 'Begg' but Biggar is correct.
  • Robert Leckie: a farmer's son from Killearn, he had a short football career before emigrating to South Africa, where he died in 1886.
  • Alexander Rhind: the man from Aberdeen had only a brief stay in Glasgow, and a year after winning his cap had returned north. Worked in the drapery business and had ten children.
  • William Muir Mackinnon: won nine Scotland caps and three Scottish Cup winners' medals, but his first love was music and when he died aged 90 his obituary was entitled 'Veteran Glasgow Musician'.
  • David Wotherspoon: best friend of Robert Gardner (he was a witness at his wedding), he also made the move to Clydesdale in 1874 after serving on the Queen's Park committee for five years. Did well in the metal trade and died in 1906.

Published on
Picture
One of the great joys of the 1872 international - 140th anniversary this week - is that there are some carefully preserved original artefacts from the match, as well as the illustrations which appeared in the Graphic. 
  •    The ticket (above) is held by the Scottish Football Museum in Glasgow. They could be bought in advance of the game from Queen's Park committee members, and despite the high price, sales were so buoyant that there were fears the ground would not cope with the anticipated large crowd. The Glasgow Herald suggested admission should be by ticket only, but then published an anxious response on the day of the game from an intending spectator: 'I do not know the committee of management, nor anyone who has tickets to dispose of, and it would be too had if I had my journey to Partick for nothing.' In the event, the crowd behaved impeccably 'and never once trenched upon the field of play'.
  •    The shirt (below left) worn by England forward Arnold Kirke Smith, in his only international, was kept by his family until 1998, when it sold at Christie's for £21,000 and is now on display in the National Football Museum - the first of eleven 'milestones in the game' that visitors see. Picture courtesy of Umbro football's photostream.
  •    Caps were not awarded specifically for this match, but Scotland's JJ Thomson made sure the honour of playing against England in 1872-3-4 was recorded on his cap (below right) when it was presented a couple of years later. It is now held at the Scottish Football Museum.

Who knows if there are any other souvenirs of the match still to be discovered?

Picture
Picture

Archives

Author

All blog posts, unless stated, are written by Andy Mitchell.