Image description

SPORTS HISTORY BLOG

Over 250 articles on all aspects of Scottish sport

Image description
Published on
Picture

Cutting from the Caledonian Mercury, 13 November 1828 (via British Newspaper Archive)

In several years of research into the Foot-Ball Club of Edinburgh, it was always thought that there was not a single mention of its activities in the papers of the day, and that the only record was John Hope's personal archive. That view can now change, with the exciting discovery of a report from 1828.
   Thanks to fellow historian Javier Terenti, I have been alerted to this cutting from the Caledonian Mercury, published on 13 November 1828. Although this newspaper has been available online for some time, the key words did not appear in OCR searches, and it was only because this snippet was then republished in a recently-digitised London paper that it was found.
   This brief report of a club dinner reveals much about the activities of the football players. For a start, it shows that the members were numerous, with 60 of them coming to the annual dinner in a Stockbridge pub. It details the breadth of their activities, not just football but also athletic exercises similar to other well-known Edinburgh clubs. And it reveals where they sometimes played, on the city's main recreational area at Bruntsfield Links, even though the club also rented Dalry Park at the time.
   Most importantly of all, however, this discovery confirms that the club was widely known about in the city at the time.
   The conviviality of a dinner was clearly important to the football players, and helps to emphasise that this was a sporting club in every essential: it had subscriptions, it had rules, it met regularly, it was active, and the members not only played together, they socialised together.
   There is also a bit of wider Edinburgh history, as the venue was a new coffee house and tavern at 4 Hamilton Place, Stockbridge - the building is still there to this day and I think it is now Caffe Nero. It was run by Charles Presgrave, who clearly wanted to cater for many more such club dinners, judging by his advert (below) which appeared a few weeks later. It seems not to have worked as he was declared insolvent the following year.
Picture

Advert in the Edinburgh Evening Courant, 4 December 1828 (via British Newspaper Archive)

Meanwhile, I recently had the privilege of talking about the story of the Foot-Ball Club and its long-term influence to the members of the Old Edinburgh Club.
   I have now published my talk and the associated PowerPoint presentation, which can be accessed on the following links in pdf form. They should be opened and read together.

Click here for the PowerPoint.
​Click here for the text of my talk.

If you are interested to read more, my book 1824, The World's First Foot-Ball Club is available price £11.99 (post free) from this website, or from Amazon.
3 Comments
P McFarlane - 7 years ago
Hi Andy,

A very interesting find, but can you be certain that this is in fact Hope’s club?

The Caledonian Mercury article (13 November, 1828) says ‘This Society, which has been established for two years’, but Hope’s club was formed in 1824.

Also, would Hope have allowed for a dinner to have been held in an establishment that sold alcohol? Or were his views on sobriety less resolute when he was younger?

As you’ve already mentioned, Hope’s club played at Dalry Park until 1831, whereas this article suggests ‘meetings’ were at Bruntsfield Links.

Finally, is there any other express reference to Hope’s club as a ‘society’?

Maybe I’m barking up the wrong tree. Certainly from your membership numbers, there were enough members in Hope’s club for sixty to attend such an event in 1828. I’d be interested to know your thoughts though. Your book on the subject was an excellent read.
P McFarlane - 7 years ago
Sorry, I just realised Hope didn't become a total abstainer until 1839, so that answers the Tavern issue.
Andy Mitchell - 7 years ago
Paul, thanks very much for your comments. I realise that there are discrepancies, but I really can't envisage there being a second Football club or society in Edinburgh at that time - that really would be a major discovery! The Bruntsfield Links mention is a surprise, as was the description of the other athletic exercises, but quite possibly they did sometimes meet there, or at least practise the other sports in the summer months. I live in hope that more contemporary reports will surface.

Archives

Author

All blog posts, unless stated, are written by Andy Mitchell.